Point mutations in Arf1 reveal cooperative effects of the N-terminal extension and myristate for GTPase-activating protein catalytic activity.

The ADP-ribosylation factors (Arfs) constitute a family of small GTPases within the Ras superfamily, with a distinguishing structural feature of a hypervariable N-terminal extension of the G domain modified with myristate. Arf proteins, including Arf1, have roles in membrane trafficking and cytoskeletal dynamics. While screening for Arf1:small molecule co-crystals, we serendipitously solved the crystal structure of the non-myristoylated engineered mutation [L8K]Arf1 in complex with a GDP analogue. Like wild-type (WT) non-myristoylated Arf1•GDP, we observed that [L8K]Arf1 exhibited an N-terminal helix that occludes the hydrophobic cavity that is occupied by the myristoyl group in the GDP-bound state of the native protein. However, the helices were offset from one another due to the L8K mutation, with a significant change in position of the hinge region connecting the N-terminus to the G domain. Hypothesizing that the observed effects on behavior of the N-terminus affects interaction with regulatory proteins, we mutated two hydrophobic residues to examine the role of the N-terminal extension for interaction with guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) and GTPase Activating Proteins (GAPs. Different than previous studies, all mutations were examined in the context of myristoylated Arf. Mutations had little or no effect on spontaneous or GEF-catalyzed guanine nucleotide exchange but did affect interaction with GAPs. [F13A]myrArf1 was less than 1/2500, 1/1500, and 1/200 efficient as substrate for the GAPs ASAP1, ARAP1 and AGAP1; however, [L8A/F13A]myrArf1 was similar to WT myrArf1. Using molecular dynamics simulations, the effect of the mutations on forming alpha helices adjacent to a membrane surface was examined, yet no differences were detected. The results indicate that lipid modifications of GTPases and consequent anchoring to a membrane influences protein function beyond simple membrane localization. Hypothetical mechanisms are discussed.

Myr-Arf1 conformational flexibility at the membrane surface sheds light on the interactions with ArfGAP ASAP1.

ADP-ribosylation factor 1 (Arf1) interacts with multiple cellular partners and membranes to regulate intracellular traffic, organelle structure and actin dynamics. Defining the dynamic conformational landscape of Arf1 in its active form, when bound to the membrane, is of high functional relevance and key to understanding how Arf1 can alter diverse cellular processes. Through concerted application of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), neutron reflectometry (NR) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we show that, while Arf1 is anchored to the membrane through its N-terminal myristoylated amphipathic helix, the G domain explores a large conformational space, existing in a dynamic equilibrium between membrane-associated and membrane-distal conformations. These configurational dynamics expose different interfaces for interaction with effectors. Interaction with the Pleckstrin homology domain of ASAP1, an Arf-GTPase activating protein (ArfGAP), restricts motions of the G domain to lock it in what seems to be a conformation exposing functionally relevant regions.

The small molecule inhibitor NAV-2729 has a complex target profile including multiple ADP-ribosylation factor regulatory proteins.

The ADP-ribosylation factor (Arf) GTPases and their regulatory proteins are implicated in cancer progression. NAV-2729 was previously identified as a specific inhibitor of Arf6 that reduced progression of uveal melanoma in an orthotopic xenograft. Here, our goal was to assess the inhibitory effects of NAV-2729 on the proliferation of additional cell types. We found NAV-2729 inhibited proliferation of multiple cell lines, but Arf6 expression did not correlate with NAV-2729 sensitivity, and knockdown of Arf6 affected neither cell viability nor sensitivity to NAV-2729. Furthermore, binding to native Arf6 was not detected; however, we determined that NAV-2729 inhibited both Arf exchange factors and Arf GTPase-activating proteins. ASAP1, a GTPase-activating protein linked to cancer progression, was further investigated. We demonstrated that NAV-2729 bound to the PH domain of ASAP1 and changed ASAP1 cellular distribution. However, ASAP1 knockdown did not fully recapitulate the cytoskeletal effects of NAV-2729 nor affect cell proliferation. Finally, our screens identified 48 other possible targets of NAV-2729. These results illustrate the complexities of defining targets of small molecules and identify NAV-2729 as a model PH domain-binding inhibitor.

Physiological changes in bilayer thickness induced by cholesterol control GPCR rhodopsin function.

We monitored the effect on function of the G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) rhodopsin from small, stepwise changes in bilayer thickness induced by cholesterol. Over a range of phosphatidylcholine bilayers with hydrophobic thickness from ≈21 Å to 38 Å, the metarhodopsin-I (MI)/metarhodopsin-II (MII) equilibrium was monitored with UV-visible spectroscopy while ordering of hydrocarbon chains was probed by 2H-NMR. Addition of cholesterol shifted equilibrium toward MII for bilayers thinner than the average length of hydrophobic transmembrane helices (27 Å) and to MI for thicker bilayers, while small bilayer thickness changes within the range of the protein hydrophobic thickness drastically up- or downregulated MII formation. The cholesterol-induced shifts toward MII for thinner membranes correlated with the cholesterol-induced increase of bilayer hydrophobic thickness measured by NMR, consistent with continuum elastic modeling. The energetic penalty of adding cholesterol to thick bilayers caused rhodopsin oligomerization and a shift toward MI. In membranes of physiological thickness, changes in bilayer mechanical properties induced by cholesterol potentiated the interplay between bilayer and protein thickness resulting in large swings of the MI-MII equilibrium. In membrane containing cholesterol, elastic deformations near the protein are a dominant energetic contribution to the functional equilibrium of the model GPCR rhodopsin.

Membrane surface recognition by the ASAP1 PH domain and consequences for interactions with the small GTPase Arf1.

Adenosine diphosphate-ribosylation factor (Arf) guanosine triphosphatase-activating proteins (GAPs) are enzymes that need to bind to membranes to catalyze the hydrolysis of guanosine triphosphate (GTP) bound to the small GTP-binding protein Arf. Binding of the pleckstrin homology (PH) domain of the ArfGAP With SH3 domain, ankyrin repeat and PH domain 1 (ASAP1) to membranes containing phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate [PI(4,5)P2] is key for maximum GTP hydrolysis but not fully understood. By combining nuclear magnetic resonance, neutron reflectometry, and molecular dynamics simulation, we show that binding of multiple PI(4,5)P2 molecules to the ASAP1 PH domain (i) triggers a functionally relevant allosteric conformational switch and (ii) maintains the PH domain in a well-defined orientation, allowing critical contacts with an Arf1 mimic to occur. Our model provides a framework to understand how binding of the ASAP1 PH domain to PI(4,5)P2 at the membrane may play a role in the regulation of ASAP1.

Optimization of sortase A ligation for flexible engineering of complex protein systems.

Engineering and bioconjugation of proteins is a critically valuable tool that can facilitate a wide range of biophysical and structural studies. The ability to orthogonally tag or label a domain within a multidomain protein may be complicated by undesirable side reactions to noninvolved domains. Furthermore, the advantages of segmental (or domain-specific) isotopic labeling for NMR, or deuteration for neutron scattering or diffraction, can be realized by an efficient ligation procedure. Common methods-expressed protein ligation, protein trans-splicing, and native chemical ligation-each have specific limitations. Here, we evaluated the use of different variants of Staphylococcus aureus sortase A for a range of ligation reactions and demonstrate that conditions can readily be optimized to yield high efficiency (i.e. completeness of ligation), ease of purification, and functionality in detergents. These properties may enable joining of single domains into multidomain proteins, lipidation to mimic posttranslational modifications, and formation of cyclic proteins to aid in the development of nanodisc membrane mimetics. We anticipate that the method for ligating separate domains into a single functional multidomain protein reported here may enable many applications in structural biology.

Interaction of the N terminus of ADP-ribosylation factor with the PH domain of the GTPase-activating protein ASAP1 requires phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate.

Arf GAP with Src homology 3 domain, ankyrin repeat, and pleckstrin homology (PH) domain 1 (ASAP1) is a multidomain GTPase-activating protein (GAP) for ADP-ribosylation factor (ARF)-type GTPases. ASAP1 affects integrin adhesions, the actin cytoskeleton, and invasion and metastasis of cancer cells. ASAP1's cellular function depends on its highly-regulated and robust ARF GAP activity, requiring both the PH and the ARF GAP domains of ASAP1, and is modulated by phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PIP2). The mechanistic basis of PIP2-stimulated GAP activity is incompletely understood. Here, we investigated whether PIP2 controls binding of the N-terminal extension of ARF1 to ASAP1's PH domain and thereby regulates its GAP activity. Using [Δ17]ARF1, lacking the N terminus, we found that PIP2 has little effect on ASAP1's activity. A soluble PIP2 analog, dioctanoyl-PIP2 (diC8PIP2), stimulated GAP activity on an N terminus-containing variant, [L8K]ARF1, but only marginally affected activity on [Δ17]ARF1. A peptide comprising residues 2-17 of ARF1 ([2-17]ARF1) inhibited GAP activity, and PIP2-dependently bound to a protein containing the PH domain and a 17-amino acid-long interdomain linker immediately N-terminal to the first ß-strand of the PH domain. Point mutations in either the linker or the C-terminal α-helix of the PH domain decreased [2-17]ARF1 binding and GAP activity. Mutations that reduced ARF1 N-terminal binding to the PH domain also reduced the effect of ASAP1 on cellular actin remodeling. Mutations in the ARF N terminus that reduced binding also reduced GAP activity. We conclude that PIP2 regulates binding of ASAP1's PH domain to the ARF1 N terminus, which may partially regulate GAP activity.

Functional Expression and Characterization of Human Myristoylated-Arf1 in Nanodisc Membrane Mimetics.

Lipidated small GTP-binding proteins of the Arf family interact with multiple cellular partners and with membranes to regulate intracellular traffic and organelle structure. Here, we focus on the ADP-ribosylation factor 1 (Arf1), which interacts with numerous proteins in the Arf pathway, such as the ArfGAP ASAP1 that is highly expressed and activated in several cancer cell lines and associated with enhanced migration, invasiveness, and poor prognosis. Understanding the molecular and mechanistic details of Arf1 regulation at the membrane via structural and biophysical studies requires large quantities of fully functional protein bound to lipid bilayers. Here, we report on the production of a functional human Arf1 membrane platform on nanodiscs for biophysical studies. Large scale bacterial production of highly pure, N-myristoylated human Arf1 has been achieved, including complex isotopic labeling for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies, and the myr-Arf1 can be readily assembled in small nanoscale lipid bilayers (nanodiscs, NDs). It is determined that myr-Arf1 requires a minimum binding surface in the NDs of ∼20 lipids. Fluorescence and NMR were used to establish nucleotide exchange and ArfGAP-stimulated GTP hydrolysis at the membrane, indicating that phophoinositide stimulation of the activity of the ArfGAP ASAP1 is ≥2000-fold. Differences in nonhydrolyzable GTP analogues are observed, and GMPPCP is found to be the most stable. Combined, these observations establish a functional environment for biophysical studies of Arf1 effectors and interactions at the membrane.

Rhodopsin/lipid hydrophobic matching-rhodopsin oligomerization and function.

Lipid composition of the membrane and rhodopsin packing density strongly modulate the early steps of the visual response of photoreceptor membranes. In this study, lipid-order and bovine rhodopsin function in proteoliposomes composed of the sn-1 chain perdeuterated lipids 14:0d27-14:1-PC, 16:0d31-16:1-PC, 18:0d35-18:1-PC, or 20:0d39-20:1-PC at rhodopsin/lipid molar ratios from 1:70 to 1:1000 (mol/mol) were investigated. Clear evidence for matching of hydrophobic regions on rhodopsin transmembrane helices and hydrophobic thickness of lipid bilayers was observed from (2)H nuclear magnetic resonance order parameter measurements at low rhodopsin concentrations. Thin bilayers stretched to match the length of transmembrane helices observed as increase of sn-1 chain order, while thicker bilayers were compressed near the protein. A quantitative analysis of lipid-order parameter changes suggested that the protein adjusts its conformation to bilayer hydrophobic thickness as well, which confirmed our earlier circular-dichroism measurements. Changes in lipid order parameters upon rhodopsin incorporation vanished for bilayers with a hydrophobic thickness of 27 ± 1 Å, suggesting that this is the bilayer thickness at which rhodopsin packs in bilayers at the lowest membrane perturbation. The lipid-order parameter studies also indicated that a hydrophobic mismatch between rhodopsin and lipids triggers rhodopsin oligomerization with increasing rhodopsin concentrations. Both hydrophobic mismatch and rhodopsin oligomerization result in substantial shifts of the equilibrium between the photointermediates metarhodopsin I and metarhodopsin II; increasing bilayer thickness favors formation of metarhodopsin II while oligomerization favors metarhodopsin I. The results highlight the importance of hydrophobic matching for rhodopsin structure, oligomerization, and function.

The role of membrane curvature elastic stress for function of rhodopsin-like G protein-coupled receptors.

The human genome encodes about 800 different G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR). They are key molecules in signal transduction pathways that transmit signals of a variety of ligands such as hormones and neurotransmitters to the cell interior. Upon ligand binding, the receptors undergo structural transitions that either enhance or inhibit transmission of a specific signal to the cell interior. Here we discuss results which indicate that transmission of such signals can be strongly modulated by the composition of the lipid matrix into which GPCR are imbedded. Experimental results have been obtained on rhodopsin, a prototype GPCR whose structure and function is representative for the great majority of GPCR in humans. The data shed light on the importance of curvature elastic stress in the lipid domain for function of GPCR.

Elastic properties of polyunsaturated phosphatidylethanolamines influence rhodopsin function.

Membranes with a high content of polyunsaturated phosphatidylethanolamines (PE) facilitate formation of metarhodopsin-II (M(II)), the photointermediate of bovine rhodopsin that activates the G protein transducin. We determined whether M(II)-formation is quantitatively linked to the elastic properties of PEs. Curvature elasticity of monolayers of the polyunsaturated lipids 18 : 0-22 : 6(n - 3)PE, 18 : 0-22 : 5(n)- 6PE and the model lipid 18 : 1(n - 9)-18 : 1,(n- 9)PE were investigated in the inverse hexagonal phase. All three lipids form lipid monolayers with rather low spontaneous radii of curvature of 26-28 angstroms. In membranes, all three PEs generate high negative curvature elastic stress that shifts the equilibrium of MI(I)/M(II) photointermediates of rhodopsin towards M(II) formation.

Rhodopsin-lipid interactions studied by NMR.

The biophysical properties of the lipid matrix are known to influence function of integral membrane proteins. We report on a sample preparation method for reconstitution of membrane proteins which uses porous anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) filters with 200-nm-wide pores of high density. The substrate permits formation of tubular, single membranes that line the inner surface of pores. One square centimeter of filter with a thickness of 60µm yields on the order of 500cm(2) of solid-supported single bilayer surface, sufficient for NMR studies. The tubular bilayers are free of detergent, fully hydrated, and accessible for ligands from one side of the membrane. The use of AAO filters greatly improves reproducibility of the reconstitution process such that the influence of protein on lipid order parameters can be studied with high resolution. As an example, results for the G protein-coupled receptor of class A, bovine rhodopsin, are shown. By (2)H NMR order parameter measurements, it is detected that rhodopsin insertion elastically deforms membranes near the protein. Furthermore, by (1)H saturation-transfer NMR under conditions of magic angle spinning, we demonstrate detection of preferences in interactions of rhodopsin with particular lipid species. It is assumed that function of integral membrane proteins depends on both protein-induced elastic deformations of the lipid matrix and preferences for interaction of the protein with particular lipid species in the first layer of lipids surrounding the protein.

Quantitative Analysis of Guanine Nucleotide Exchange Factors (GEFs) as Enzymes.

The proteins that possess guanine nucleotide exchange factor (GEF) activity, which include about ~800 G protein coupled receptors (GPCRs),1 15 Arf GEFs,2 81 Rho GEFs,3 8 Ras GEFs,4 and others for other families of GTPases,5 catalyze the exchange of GTP for GDP on all regulatory guanine nucleotide binding proteins. Despite their importance as catalysts, relatively few exchange factors (we are aware of only eight for ras superfamily members) have been rigorously characterized kinetically.5-13 In some cases, kinetic analysis has been simplistic leading to erroneous conclusions about mechanism (as discussed in a recent review14). In this paper, we compare two approaches for determining the kinetic properties of exchange factors: (i) examining individual equilibria, and; (ii) analyzing the exchange factors as enzymes. Each approach, when thoughtfully used,14,15 provides important mechanistic information about the exchange factors. The analysis as enzymes is described in further detail. With the focus on the production of the biologically relevant guanine nucleotide binding protein complexed with GTP (G•GTP), we believe it is conceptually simpler to connect the kinetic properties to cellular effects. Further, the experiments are often more tractable than those used to analyze the equilibrium system and, therefore, more widely accessible to scientists interested in the function of exchange factors.

The role of the lipid matrix for structure and function of the GPCR rhodopsin.

Photoactivation of rhodopsin in lipid bilayers results within milliseconds in a metarhodopsin I (MI)-metarhodopsin II (MII) equilibrium that is very sensitive to the lipid composition. It has been well established that lipid bilayers that are under negative curvature elastic stress from incorporation of lipids like phosphatidylethanolamines (PE) favor formation of MII, the rhodopsin photointermediate that is capable of activating G protein. Furthermore, formation of the MII state is favored by negatively charged lipids like phosphatidylserine and by lipids with longer hydrocarbon chains that yield bilayers with larger membrane hydrophobic thickness. Cholesterol and rhodopsin-rhodopsin interactions from crowding of rhodopsin molecules in lipid bilayers shift the MI-MII equilibrium towards MI. A variety of mechanisms seems to be responsible for the large, lipid-induced shifts between MI and MII: adjustment of the thickness of lipid bilayers to rhodopsin and adjustment of rhodopsin helicity to the thickness of bilayers, curvature elastic deformations in the lipid matrix surrounding the protein, direct interactions of PE headgroups and polyunsaturated hydrocarbon chains with rhodopsin, and direct or lipid-mediated interactions between rhodopsin molecules. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Membrane protein structure and function.

Structure and dynamics of cholesterol-containing polyunsaturated lipid membranes studied by neutron diffraction and NMR.

A direct and quantitative analysis of the internal structure and dynamics of a polyunsaturated lipid bilayer composed of 1-stearoyl-2-docosahexaenoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (18:0-22:6n3-PC) containing 29 mol% cholesterol was carried out by neutron diffraction, (2)H-NMR and (13)C-MAS NMR. Scattering length distribution functions of cholesterol segments as well as of the sn-1 and sn-2 hydrocarbon chains of 18:0-22:6n3-PC were obtained by conducting experiments with specifically deuterated cholesterol and lipids. Cholesterol orients parallel to the phospholipids, with the A-ring near the lipid glycerol and the terminal methyl groups 3 Å away from the bilayer center. Previously, we reported that the density of polyunsaturated docosahexaenoic acid (DHA, 22:6n3) chains was higher near the lipid-water interface. Addition of cholesterol partially redistributes DHA density from near the lipid-water interface to the center of the hydrocarbon region. Cholesterol raises chain-order parameters of both stearic acid and DHA chains. The fractional order increase for stearic acid methylene carbons C(8)-C(18) is larger, reflecting the redistribution of DHA chain density toward the bilayer center. The correlation times of DHA chain isomerization are short and mostly unperturbed by the presence of cholesterol. The uneven distribution of saturated and polyunsaturated chain densities and the cholesterol-induced balancing of chain distributions may have important implications for the function and integrity of membrane receptors, such as rhodopsin.

Contribution of membrane elastic energy to rhodopsin function.

We considered the issue of whether shifts in the metarhodopsin I (MI)-metarhodopsin II (MII) equilibrium from lipid composition are fully explicable by differences in bilayer curvature elastic stress. A series of six lipids with known spontaneous radii of monolayer curvature and bending elastic moduli were added at increasing concentrations to the matrix lipid 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) and the MI-MII equilibrium measured by flash photolysis followed by recording UV-vis spectra. The average area-per-lipid molecule and the membrane hydrophobic thickness were derived from measurements of the (2)H NMR order parameter profile of the palmitic acid chain in POPC. For the series of ethanolamines with different levels of headgroup methylation, shifts in the MI-MII equilibrium correlated with changes in membrane elastic properties as expressed by the product of spontaneous radius of monolayer curvature, bending elastic modulus, and lateral area per molecule. However, for the entire series of lipids, elastic energy explained the shifts only partially. Additional contributions correlated with the capability of the ethanolamine headgroups to engage in hydrogen bonding with the protein, independent of the state of ethanolamine methylation, with introduction of polyunsaturated sn-2 hydrocarbon chains, and with replacement of the palmitic acid sn-1 chains by oleic acid. The experiments point to the importance of interactions of rhodopsin with particular lipid species in the first layer of lipids surrounding the protein as well as to membrane elastic stress in the lipid-protein domain.

Insights from biophysical studies on the role of polyunsaturated fatty acids for function of G-protein coupled membrane receptors.

The composition of the lipid matrix is critical for function of membrane proteins. Perhaps one of the best studied examples is the function of the G-protein-coupled membrane receptor (GPCR) rhodopsin which is located in membranes with high content of phospholipids with polyunsaturated docosahexaenoic acid chains (DHA, 22:6n-3). Technological advances enabled a more detailed study of structure and dynamics of DHA chains and their interaction with rhodopsin. It was established that polyunsaturated DHA differs from saturated and monounsaturated hydrocarbon chains by far more rapid structural conversions. Furthermore, DHA chains tend to have higher density near the lipid/water interface while density of saturated chains is higher in the bilayer center. The interface of rhodopsin has a small number of sites for tighter interaction with DHA. Polyunsaturated phosphatidylethanolamines accumulate preferentially near the protein. Surprisingly, the high conformational freedom of most DHA chains is not measurably reduced upon interaction with rhodopsin. While some observations point at an involvement of continuum elastic properties of membranes in modulation of rhodopsin function, there is growing evidence for a role of weakly specific DHA-rhodopsin interactions.

Lipid-rhodopsin hydrophobic mismatch alters rhodopsin helical content.

The ability of photoactivated rhodopsin to achieve the enzymatically active metarhodopsin II conformation is exquisitely sensitive to bilayer hydrophobic thickness. The sensitivity of rhodopsin to the lipid matrix has been explained by the hydrophobic matching theory, which predicts that lipid bilayers adjust elastically to the hydrophobic length of transmembrane helices. Here, we examined if bilayer thickness adjusts to the length of the protein or if the protein alters its conformation to adapt to the bilayer. Purified bovine rhodopsin was reconstituted into a series of mono-unsaturated phosphatidylcholines with 14-20 carbons per hydrocarbon chain. Changes of hydrocarbon chain length were measured by (2)H NMR, and protein helical content was quantified by synchrotron radiation circular dichroism and conventional circular dichroism. Experiments were conducted on dark-adapted rhodopsin, the photo-intermediates metarhodopsin I/II/III, and opsin. Changes of bilayer thickness upon rhodopsin incorporation and photoactivation were mostly absent. In contrast, the helical content of rhodopsin increased with membrane hydrophobic thickness. Helical content did not change measurably upon photoactivation. The increases of bilayer thickness and helicity of rhodopsin are accompanied by higher metarhodopsin II/metarhodopsin I ratios, faster rates of metarhodopsin II formation, an increase of tryptophan fluorescence, and higher temperatures of rhodopsin denaturation. The data suggest a surprising adaptability of this G protein-coupled membrane receptor to properties of the lipid matrix.